Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
The controversial Internet surveillance tool known as Carnivore has been renamed DCS1000, a name devoid of any negative associations, the Federal Bureau of Investigation said on Tuesday.
"With upgrades come new names," said Paul Bresson, an FBI spokesman. The old name of a flesh-eating predator had conjured up "unfortunate" images for many people, he added.
The system in question is specialized software installed on an Internet service provider's network under federal wiretap authority. Used in criminal and national security cases, it is capable of keeping tabs on a suspect's email, instant messages, and Web surfing activities.
Privacy and civil-rights advocates have argued that the system violates Fourth Amendment protections against unreasonable search and seizure. Former Attorney General Janet Reno ordered an independent review of its inner workings after a stir in Congress.
The name change was to have been rolled out in conjunction with an internal Justice Department review to be presented to Attorney General John Ashcroft soon, an FBI official said. But the change was leaked to a trade publication, Government Computer News.
"Had it not been called Carnivore, it probably wouldn't have stirred as much controversy," Bresson said. He added that the new alpha-numeric "doesn't stand for anything."
In response, critics contend that the FBI was kidding itself if it thought a name change alone would allay fears. They consider the system ripe for abuse, largely because of the way it scans data to find its court-authorized target.
"It's not the name that worries people," said David Sobel of the Washington-based Electronic Privacy Information Center, which has sued the FBI and the Justice Department for the source code and other data about the spy tool formerly known as Carnivore. "It's the way this system works."
Barry Steinhardt, associate director of the American Civil Liberties Union, added: "If it prowls like a wolf, howls like a wolf, and has the voracious appetite of a wolf, it's still a carnivore."
For very different reasons, the new name fell flat with Naseem Javed, the New York-based author of Naming for Power, a book about business naming, and Domain Wars, a book about cyberspace names.
The FBI should have seized the opportunity to name the system in a "friendly way," as would any company seeking to score points with the public, Javed said.
"I think they had a bad name to begin with," he continued, adding that DCS1000 was worse because combinations of letters and numbers sow confusion.
"They need a proper name branding so they can roll this out as a readily identifiable tool for law enforcement," he said. Javed declined to rename the wiretapping system on the spot, however, saying it would take him weeks to come up with a good name.
I dont think they get it
Its not the damn name were mad about its the corruption of the fourth and our privacy
I wonder if they know what the CONSTITUTION is ?
1 Posted on 02/17/2001 03:55:14 PST by ATOMIC_PUNK
I think with the previous administration, Carnivore was an appropriate name....as they were more interested in destroying peoples lives by the mud that they sling.
2 Posted on 02/17/2001 04:08:45 PST by RasterMaster
Ridiculous line of reasoning. Rename it and people will love it. What a crock.
3 Posted on 02/17/2001 04:16:40 PST by NoControllingLegalAuthority
War is peace.
4 Posted on 02/17/2001 04:19:27 PST by Rustynailww
A new and more privacy intolerant surveillance system called:
Carnivore II
has been announced by the FBI.
Oh yeah, like no one's gonna fail to call it Carnivore II.
5 Posted on 02/17/2001 04:30:51 PST by GotDangGenius
Maybe they should've renamed it "Carnivore LITE" <|:)~
6 Posted on 02/17/2001 04:55:15 PST by martin_fierro
Hey, maybe they could even have renamed it "Carnivore ME"! :)
7 Posted on 02/17/2001 05:35:17 PST by martin_fierro
This is too easy. Now it's the Damned Carnivore Sytstem 1000. Maybe the people in charge of the new name have a sense of humor.
8 Posted on 02/17/2001 08:01:57 PST by litany_of_lies
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
[ Top | Latest Posts
| Latest
Articles | Self Search
| Add Bookmark
| Post | Abuse | Help! ]
|
FreeRepublic , LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 Forum Version 2.0a Copyright © 1999 Free Republic, LLC |